If, like me, you somehow managed to miss the late-night-talk-show-host-wars, Rodman Flender’s film will catch you up, but here’s the gist, as I see it: O’Brien turns down what for many would be the gig of a lifetime, and walks away with a fat cash settlement, the massed goodwill of the Internets, and an injunction restricting him from TV appearances for a little while. What to do with the no-tv-time? As the title of this documentary informs you, he definitely can’t stop, so he mounts a tour in which, somewhat oddly, he mixes comedy with live classic rock & soul*; this film basically documents that tour from the germination of the idea through the last shows.
I certainly didn’t dislike this movie, but I also didn’t love it. I think what bothers me most about it is that it’s just not very surprising. It certainly creates the impression of candor (Flender corroborated this in the Q&A: he said O’Brien did not ask for unflattering material to be cut). But the putatively candid O’Brien is more-or-less as you might imagine him: he’s engaging and interesting (well, duh), he’s ambitious and driven (again, duh), he’s funny off-stage (so there are definitely some laughs in the film), he seems like he’d be a challenging co-worker (his long-suffering assistant Sona Movsesian perhaps emerges as the real hero), and he has a very ambivalent push-pull relationship with his fans (throughout the film he goes above and beyond the call of celeb duty to be nice to strangers, then expresses resentment afterward).
Of course, this observation is more about the nature of the film’s subject than the merits of the film, which I thought did a good job of presenting this not-terribly-startling picture of a big TV star. It’s paced well, and I think Flender selected enough moments from his copious footage to build an impression of character without having too many sequences that illuminated O’Brien in exactly the same way. (Arguably, the most redundant moments in terms of character-building are among the funniest, so they don’t seem problematic.) I would have put in somewhat less of the live music footage, but that’s probably just me.
And if I were a big-time fan of O’Brien I might well have totally loved it.
* It would be easy, but unduly harsh, to make a crack like “as a singer and guitarist O’Brien is a pretty good comedian”; in fact he seems sturdily competent at both. But I can’t imagine he’d have had a career that led to selling out mid-sized theatres if that had been his main gig.
Brilliant list! I just caught sight of it 2 weeks post-Thanksgiving, but it is making me feel very thankful today.