contendahs

19 May 2005, 9:00 am

summervillain’s extremely biased running list of contenders for best music released in 2005

update
My top ten list (with capsule reviews) is online at Avoid Peril.


(months are when i first heard it, not necessarily when it was released.)

eM = is (possibly was) available at eMusic

open division:

  • Architecture in Helsinki - In Case We Die (Bar/None; eM)(may)
  • Audible - Sky Signal (Polyvinyl) (eM)(feb)
  • **Steve Barton - Charm Offensive (Sleepless/Redeye) (eM)(feb)
  • **Andrew Bird - The Mysterious Production of Eggs (Righteous Babe)(mar)
  • Black Lipstick - Sincerely, Black Lipstick (Peekaboo)(eM)(mar)
  • The Deathray Davies - The Kick and the Snare (aug)
  • Ad Frank - Is the World’s Best Ex-Boyfriend (eM)(apr)
  • Gem - Tell Me What’s New (eM)(apr)
    Note: not the Doug Gillard Gem. From Utrecht.
  • The Gena Rowlands Band - La Merde et Les Etoiles (Lujo)(apr)
  • Headphones - Headphones (Suicide Squeeze)(eM) (aug)
  • *Ida - Heart Like a River (Polyvinyl) (eM)(feb)
  • **Low - The Great Destroyer (SubPop)(feb)
  • New Pornographers - Twin Cinema (Matador) (eM)(aug)
  • Pernice Brothers - Discover a Lovelier You (Ashmont)(eM) (jul)
  • Portastatic - Bright Ideas (Merge)(eM) (aug)
  • Maria McKee - Peddlin’ Dreams (eM)(apr)
  • The Mountain Goats - Sunset Tree (4AD; eM)(may)
  • *Transistor Transistor - Erase All Name and Likeness (Level Plane)(eM)(apr)

local/hopelessly indie division:

  • Gatsby - Floods + Fires (gatsbymusic)(feb)
  • Hoover’s G-string - Elephant Parts (Red Tide)(jun)
  • The Information - Mistakes We Knew We Were Making (feb)

not (quite) contendahs

Here are some records that I don’t think are consistent enough to warrant contendah status, but have some really good individual tracks on them.

  • Foetus, Love (Birdman)
    “Pareidolia,” “Time Marches On,” “Don’t Want Me Anymore”
  • Okkervil River, Black Sheep Boy (Jagjaguwar)
    Too florid and overblown for me to like unreservedly, but sometimes catchy enough to compentsate
  • Snitches Get Stiches - I Liked You Better When You Were a Corpse(eM)(apr)

still evaluamatin’

Records I want to spend more time with before coming to a final opinion. Either too complex to assess immediately, or are problematic in ways I might ultimately decide they compensate for. Or both.

  • Gloria Deluxe Accidental Nostalgia (jun)
  • Veda Hille Return of the Kildeer (jun)

the summervillain really wants to hear:

  • new ep from The Beatings
  • new Deathray Davies (glurp)
  • The Futureheads (2004)
  • new Harris
  • new Veda Hille (?label)(Thanks!)
  • Lucksmiths Warmer Corners
  • Okkervil River Black Sheep Boy (jun)

2 comments on “contendahs”

  1. 2fs

    What do the asterisks designate?

  2. summervillain

    mo’ asterisks is mo’ better.
    mountain goats should prolly get an asterisk, but i should prolly listen again first.

Comment

Comments are subject to moderation. Unless you have been whitelisted, your comment will not appear on the site until it is approved. Links are allowed for whitelisted commenters; images are not permitted.